2543 Shares

Were there any events in the history of US when unconstitutional decisions had to be made?

Were there any events in the history of US when unconstitutional decisions had to be made? Topic: Supreme court case summaries
May 25, 2019 / By Florinda
Question: Were there any events in the history of US when unconstitutional decisions had to be made by any president or his administration? If so, what were they? And what were some events in history when the US acted in defense? Thank you.
Best Answer

Best Answers: Were there any events in the history of US when unconstitutional decisions had to be made?

Dalya Dalya | 5 days ago
I don't quite know if you are asking whether the Supreme Court has determined if an action by an American President was unconstitutional. For that I would suggest looking at Supreme Court rulings and just look at the summary of their rulings. I just found this with 2 minutes of searching...U.S. Supreme Court Justice Earl Warren delivered the unanimous ruling in the landmark civil rights case Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas. State-sanctioned segregation of public schools was a violation of the 14th amendment and was therefore unconstitutional. But off the top of my head...the Japanese internment camps during WWII come to mind...as do Lincoln's call for Martial Law...but both of those examples come from war time and were defended as part of the President's War Powers as Commander-in-Chief, which in my opinion is not a good enough defense for taking away the rights and privileges of American citizens. If i'm not mistaken there were some aspects of the New Deal that were considered unconstitutional but I don't remember if it was ruled as such by the Supreme Court.
👍 198 | 👎 5
Did you like the answer? Were there any events in the history of US when unconstitutional decisions had to be made? Share with your friends

We found more questions related to the topic: Supreme court case summaries


Dalya Originally Answered: I have a problem making big decisions (or any decisions for that matter) question is at bottom?
From your question- I can tell that you are a procrastinator. Procrastinators put things off until the last minute in favor of doing other, more appealing activities. I suggest that you write yourself a schedule for the day and try to stick to it. Schedule time for school, homework, snacks, and some fun time for relaxing or playing games. Write a schedule every day or use the same schedule for each weekday. Just don't out off writing the schedule! If your school offers a class in time management, study skills, or college planning, try to take it. The only way to break the habit of procrastination is to force yourself to do things that you don't want to do. This means making a concious effort to NOT turn on the television or the computer and do your homework. Since you fear not doing things well, ask yourself if you are doing your best work by putting something off until the last minute and rushing to get it done. Ask yourself how much better you could have done had you put in more time on an assignment. There is no quick-fix forprocrastination and it's going to take work, but you can do it. Don't give up! As for decision making- realize that you are going to make mistakes, and that's okay. Think about what you like to do and make a list of all your skills. The make a list of all the jobs you think you would like to have, if you don't already know. Choose a college that offers a variety of majors so you can switch. It is very common for a college student to change majors (I changed mine the first day I entered school!) and you don't have to know what you want to do before you go to college.

Blossom Blossom
The two above me are exceptional answers, with the course cases with Lincoln being "ex parte Milligan" and "ex parte Merryman", and "Korematsu v. US" upholding Japanese Internment. I would just add that another instance was the Supreme Court Case "Schenck v. US" in 1919, where the Court ruled that the First Amendment (in this case, freedom of speech) was not absolute, giving the example of shouting "fire" in a movie theater when there actually wasn't one. This Decision concerned the Espionage Acts during WWI.
👍 80 | 👎 4

Aisling Aisling
Lincoln ignored parts of the Constitution during the Civil War - banning habeas corpus and jailing dissenters/people in the North who opposed war with the South. In 1861, Lincoln had already suspended civil law in territories where resistance to the North's military power would be dangerous. In 1862, when copperhead democrats (they wanted peace with the Confederacy) began ccriticisingLincoln's violation of the Constitution, Lincoln suspended habeas corpus throughout the nation and had many of them arrested under military authority because he felt that the State Courts in the north west would not convict war protesters such as the copperheads. He proclaimed that all persons who discouraged enlistments or engaged in disloyal practices would come under Martial Law.
👍 76 | 👎 3

Trafford Trafford
television promoted a shopper-friendly custom It became the 1st election to apply televised debates. The political emphasis located on conformity antagonized black voters. the election of Dwight D. Eisenhower as president the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the voting Rights Act of 1965 conflict on Poverty. Brown v. Board of preparation the invention of Soviet missiles in communist Cuba the perception that if one Southeast Asia united states fell to communism, others might stick to Gulf of Tonkin decision america became interfering in yet another united states's civil conflict The Tet Offensive became a military victory for the South and a psychological victory for the North. the fall of Saigon brought about a unified, communist Vietnam. Wouldnt have responded if i wasnt confident
👍 72 | 👎 2

Trafford Originally Answered: What are some very important events in history in this year?
The US scaled up the military presence in Vietnam by sending in Military Advisory Groups [MAG groups] to assist in training South Vietnamese troops in their own installations. The umbrella it fell under was 'Counter Insurgency' George Jones recorded 'Open Pit Mine' and it got into the top 10 on the charts for several weeks. There are some other biggies but I ain't going to tell you what they are. Websearch the year.

If you have your own answer to the question supreme court case summaries, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.